• The Bar
  • The Rickhouse
  • Whiskey 101
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • The Rickhouse
    • By Age
    • By Classification
    • By Price
  • The Bar
    • By Flavor
    • By Occasion
    • By Season
  • Whiskey 101
  • Blog
  • Contact

Neatly Sipped

NAS, Bourbon Reviews, $20-$29, Small Batch, Straight Whiskey · November 27, 2023

Benchmark Small Batch

It’s time to meet the small batch offering from the Benchmark collection. 

Benchmark is one of the newest spinoff collections from Buffalo Trace. Despite the fact that, like all Buffalo Trace products, it’s almost impossible to find these days, the collection is marketed as a more approachable, accessible, and affordable collection compared to heavy-hitters like Blanton’s, Eagle Rare, or E.H. Taylor. The Benchmark collection currently includes: Top Floor, Bonded, Full Proof, Single Barrel, Old No. 8 Brand, and Small Batch. 

Benchmark Small Batch may be renowned for being a Buffalo Trace product, but a big reputation doesn’t guarantee big facts. The bourbon is aged four years and bottled at 90 proof, but the mashbill, number of barrels in the small batch, or really anything else are still a mystery. Guess that’s the tradeoff for being accessible and affordable. Aloofness aside though, the flavor of this bourbon says enough. 

The start of Benchmark Small Batch begins with very subtle vanilla flavors that give way to a thick caramel taste. Toward the end, a fairly deep oak flavor sinks in that kind of peeters out in the finish. Overall, the flavors are a bit thin and certainly not complex. The bourbon sweetness comes through, sure, but it feels underdeveloped and a little one note. Honestly, its 90 proof may be to blame for the flatness in the flavor. The truth is, Benchmark Small Batch is just fine – it’s a solid and sturdy bourbon that’s easy enough to enjoy. It could be satisfying enough, and not so irritating, if it weren’t for all of its pesky siblings. After all, being part of a collection basically begs for comparison. 

Sadly, comparison doesn’t do much in favor of Benchmark Small Batch. Holding it up to say, Benchmark Full Proof, is definitely disappointing with Full Proof’s big personality and bigger proof. Even next to Benchmark Single Barrel, which felt markedly middle of the road, the small batch is struggling to make an impression.  

It’s tricky to try and wrestle out distinct characteristics and personalities from every expression in a collection. However, in the case of poor Benchmark Small Batch the biggest characteristics are small impressions and small flavors. 

STATS: Benchmark Small Batch Bourbon

  • Price for us: $26 for 750 mL 
  • Proof: 90
  • Aged: NAS
  • Distillery: Buffalo Trace, owned by the Sazerac Company
  • Recommendation: Mixer

Posted In: NAS, Bourbon Reviews, $20-$29, Small Batch, Straight Whiskey · Tagged: Bourbon, Benchmark, Buffalo Trace

You’ll Also Love

Benchmark Top Floor
Left Hand
Bourbon Lift
Next Post >

Black Demure

Still Browsing?

You can browse by spirit, price, age statement, or classification to find the perfect whiskey bottle or whiskey cocktail.

Browse by Spirit

  • American Single Malt
  • Bourbon
  • Irish Whiskey
  • Rye Whiskey
  • Scotch
  • Wheat Whiskey

Browse by Price

  • Under $20
  • $20-$29
  • $30-$39
  • $40-$49
  • $50-$59
  • Over $60

Browse by Age

  • NAS
  • 2-3 Years
  • 4 Years
  • 5-8 Years
  • 9-12 Years

Browse by Classification

  • Barrel Proof
  • Bottled-in-Bond
  • Double Barrel
  • Single Barrel
  • Small Batch
  • Straight Whiskey

Latest on Instagram

Is the Top Floor top notch? Read the full review o Is the Top Floor top notch? Read the full review of Benchmark Top Floor at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #washingtondc #happyhour #benchmark #buffalotrace
A drink that always comes in handy. Find the full A drink that always comes in handy. Find the full recipe for the Left Hand cocktail at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #happyhour #cocktails #cocktailsofinstagram #cocktailgram #behindthebar #craftycocktails #drinkup #cocktailculture #drinkstagram #drinkoftheday #lefthand #milkandhoney #nyc
The Bitter Truth: Everything you need to know abou The Bitter Truth: Everything you need to know about cocktail bitters. Read the full post at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #washingtondc #happyhour #cocktails #cocktailbitters #bitters #angostura #feebrothers #bittermens
Need a tip for what to drink this St. Patty's Day? Need a tip for what to drink this St. Patty's Day? Try the Tipperary. Find the recipe at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #happyhour #cocktails #cocktailsofinstagram #cocktailgram #behindthebar #craftycocktails #drinkup #cocktailculture #drinkstagram #drinkoftheday #tipperary #deadrabbit #nyc
Celebrate St. Patrick's Day with the newest toast Celebrate St. Patrick's Day with the newest toast of Ireland. Find the full review of Slane Irish Whiskey at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #washingtondc #happyhour #irishwhiskey #brownforman #slane #slanewhiskey #slanecastle
After almost a century of the status quo, Irish Wh After almost a century of the status quo, Irish Whiskey is said to be going through its own "Renaissance." Read everything you need to know about Irish Whiskey at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #Ireland #Irishwhiskey #tullamore #slane #sexton #stpattysday #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #happyhour #cocktails #cocktailsofinstagram #cocktailgram #behindthebar #craftycocktails #drinkup #cocktailculture #drinkstagram #drinkoftheday
Put an extra lift in your day with the Bourbon Lif Put an extra lift in your day with the Bourbon Lift. Find the recipe for the Bourbon Lift at the link in our bio. ⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
⁠
#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #bourbonreview #happyhour #cocktails #cocktailsofinstagram #cocktailgram #behindthebar #craftycocktails #drinkup #cocktailculture #drinkstagram #drinkoftheday #bourbonlift #eggcream
For some, to Noe this bourbon is to love it. Find For some, to Noe this bourbon is to love it. Find the full review of Basil Hayden bourbon at the link in our bio 

#neatlysipped #bourbon #bourbonwhiskey #whiskey #whiskeyreview #kentucky #kentuckybourbon #drinks #jimbeam
#basilhayden
#bourbonreview #washingtondc #happyhour

Copyright © 2025 Neatly Sipped · Theme by 17th Avenue